Thursday, 25. August 2011
So….not to harp on the whole Google Plus thing again…. but I got my suspension notice yesterday.
I’m actually not in the group of “I want to use a fake name on Google Plus!” – initially I actually used my real name. Hell, I actually used a real photo of really myself for it – something I don’t recall I’ve *ever* done before.
I am in the group that doesn’t want the Google Plus name to be everything, especially if it must be your full, legal name. I honestly don’t remember when I started using Google – it’s been that long. I use a number of their services – Docs, Picasa, Reader, Google ID (for commenting on blogs). I’ve used these for years, and used various forms of my name, depending on how public it is – G-mail gets my first initial and full last name as if I’m e-mailing you you probably know at least that much, Google ID gets only first and last initials. It’s pretty public, and I really don’t want it attached to my private life – my job’s been threatened once because of relatively benign activity and, for all I complain about it, I would like to keep my job. Unfortunately my name is one in a million – you do a search for my name? You’re finding *me*.
Anyway, back to the point. Upon finding that my Google Plus name suddenly becomes my Google ID name, Picasa name, etc. I put it on lockdown to the least revealing name possible – which boils down to my initials, what I’ve been using on Google ID for years.
Since this naming debacle began, as my previous post states, I basically gave up on Google Plus. Why waste time and energy posting to a site that a) almost none of my friends are one and b) I will probably get banned from very soon?
I still checked in every few days though, and it’s a good thing, because although you will get multiple redundant notifications for any activity relating to anything on your Google Plus account (ooh, Michele’s like’d my post and commented on it? That deserves no fewer than two e-mails and two color boxes!) I suppose suspension does not rate as high. There was absolutely no notice besides the one posted to my profile.
Deleting Google Plus is certainly an option, but there have been cases where a removal of Google Plus had led to a lockdown of other services, including G-mail. Now, I’m not sure whether this has also applied to voluntary deletions or simple bans, but, as I’ve been using Google for years I’ve grown dependent enough on them that I worry about even *risking* deletion of my G-mail account. That’s….that’s where I keep all my stuff!
So what to do, what to do?
Oh! I know!
I’ll make up a completely fake name!
It will have the same initials as my name, but have any other similarity to my real name at all!
So I enter this fake name.
By the end of the day?
The suspension notice disappears.
That’s it. No additional fuss, no additional muss.
Moral of the story: Google’s real names and connected-ness policy, in an attempt to force everyone to use their real names so as to create an internet where people are easily identified to be held accountable for statements online and found by friends and family has just forced me to change my half-decade old Google ID association, but it did not actually require it to be my real name. So not only do people I’ve interacted with for half a decade online not know who, let’s say, Sam Tuttle is (being able to recognize S T far more easily and be all, “oh, that’s the yob who mouths off about gays and science and science about gays”), it also prevents me from just saying to friends and family, “Oh, I’m just going by my initials” – something they’d be able to remember and look up. When I’m looking up people, I actually do try different versions of their name. Joe Smith on Facebook might be Joseph S. on Metafilter and might be JTdog on Twitter. You know who I don’t expect Joe to be? ”James Samson”. I wouldn’t investigate that name further the way I might even something like jtdog.
Blech. But anyway. Now I’ve got my fully-approved fake name.
And what will I do with this fake-name Google Plus account? Will I spout garbage with it and insult people willy-nilly? Isn’t that all pseudonyms do?
No. Because being able to hide behind a fake name does not automatically make you into a jerk. Of course, being able to hide behind a fake name does allow someone to say stuff like, “sometimes my boss is a jerk” or “my student plagiarized and both she and the Dean are made at me what!?” without fear of repercussion.
But, bottom line, this Google name business isn’t helping people, and it’s certainly not doing what Google intended it to do. They need to give it up.
Sincerely,
Sam…Smith…son. Yeah. That’s it.